Cluster Bomb and Singapore's Role as a Merchant of Death?
The article below was lifted off "The Online Citizen - Campaign the Singapore Government to stop producing cluster bombs published on the 23 May 2008."
The Singapore government, through its government-linked company, Singapore Technologies Kinetics Ltd (ST Kinetics), manufactures, stockpiles and publicly advertises two types of cluster ammunitions for sale (Cluster Munition Coalition 2008) .
They are the ‘155mm DPICM artillery projectiles (containing 63 or 49 grenades) equipped with electro- mechanical self-destruct fuzes with an advertised dud rate of 3 percent’ and ‘a 120mm mortar bomb which delivers 25 DPICM grenades’ (Singapore Technologies Engineering n.d., cited in Cluster Munition Coalition, 2008 ).
As world governmental representatives converged in Dublin on the 19th May to seek an agreement on banning cluster bombs, the absence of major producers such as United States, China and Russia have seriously undermined these efforts (Gergely 2008) . The U.N. Development Programme claimed that ‘cluster munitions have caused more than 13,000 confirmed injuries and deaths around the world, the vast majority of them in Laos, Vietnam and Afghanistan‘ (Gergely 2008).
In a brief online scan of Singapore’s two major newspapers, TODAY and Straits Times, dating 16 to 20 May, both well-read newspapers in the country have remained silent over this issue. The online blogosophere has also been muted on Singapore’s role in possessing such bombs.
Singapore has also not attended the international conferences held in Oslo, Lima, Vienna, and Wellington which seek to prohibit the use of cluster bombs. As of April 2008, Singapore remains not having subscribed to the Wellington Declaration which affirms the countries’ “objective of concluding the negotiation of such an instrument prohibiting cluster munitions that cause unacceptable harm to civilians’. The declaration is a prerequisite to full participation in the conference in Dublin (Cluster Coalition Munition, 2008).
Cluster munitions can cause excessive harm to civilians even when the conflict has been over for it ‘can remain a threat for decades’. It is primarily a weapon which contains ‘multiple explosive submunitions’ which are ‘dropped from aircrafts or fired from the ground and designed to break open in mid-air, releasing the submunitions and saturating an area that can be the size of several football fields. Anybody within that area, be they military or civilian, is very likely to be killed or seriously injured’.
Those that are not exploded, and most of them don’t, ‘are left on the ground and, like landmines, remain a fatal threat’. As such, people are prevented from using ‘their land and to access schools and hospitals’. Cluster munitions have been used since the Second World War and most recently in Lebanon in 2006 (Cluster Munition Coalition Ireland 2008). Given that the world-wide trend is towards banning cluster bombs; and that the Singapore government has remained steadfastly committed to manufacturing and selling such munitions, Singaporeans should be duly concerned about these weapons being used against innocent civilians.
What then, can Singaporeans do, given that the media has not reported on this issue?
They can:
1. Act as citizen journalists by highlighting this issue in their website or blog.
2. Sign and forward the petition which is to campaign on the ban at Dublin .
3. Execute a nation-wide campaign to pressurise the government into entering into negotiations with the aim to ban cluster bombs.
4. Write to their MPs and urge them to field questions about this issue during Question Time in Parliament; or to the Opposition, appealing to them to take up this cause.
5. Tell everyone you know about Singapore’s involvement as a producer of cluster munitions and its detrimental effects.
It is a known fact that ST kinetics is a local state-affiliated company who does a lot of military hardware design and production. Of course, economies of scale matters and most of the items designed and produced are often also available for sale through its military contract overseas. So don't be surprise that a local designed weapon variant shows up in North America or something. Also, if wiki can be trusted, Ultimax 100 is a staple weapon with the US Marines.
Singapore is also pretty low profile in their research projects. This secrecy actually works in their favour. Helping to shroud everything will prevent the sparking off an arms race in the region. I am sure potential aggressors will be very interested in what kind of armaments we are producing for sale as an indication of what we actually have in stock in our arsenal.
I don't know much about the weapons we have in the arsenal in singapore. From what I gather, the 155mm DPICM round is designed to air burst and spread its munition around the targeted area of which it may either, explode on impact, explode after delay or explode when triggered as a mine.
If that is difficult to understand, just go and catch Iron-man and watch the part where Tony Starks test-launch the Jericho missile and its repulsor technology. That scene itself should convince you of its lethality or its awesomeness or whatever.
The issue now is that normal civillian might get killed if they come in contact with such munitions and the obvious lethality of such munitions may persist long after the war has ended...
After weighing the pros and cons, I am for the production of such munitions and the continous deployment of such munitions.
The pros:
1) It's profitable.
Munition sales goes into millions every year. Of course, the figure is not just for cluster bombs. But it is still profitable. If somebody has to produce and sell it, why not Singapore?
2) Bombs are doing what they are designed for specifically.
The cluster bomb does its intended purpose very well. Too well in fact. But every war and conflict has its collateral damage. The unavoidable tradeoff. After reading up on so much armed conflicts on the internet, none of the conflict documented actually shows a zero civillian casualty rate. In fact, innocent people who die from gun wounds run into thousands as well. Do we ban guns next?
3) Bombs help to win war.
With that I mean that the right munition can help to win war thus shortening the sufferings of the common people. This also means that innocent casualty figures don't climb more then can be avoided.
Personally, I think that the fact that US, Russia and China are not committed to the cease cluster bomb treaty itself has effectively undermined its usefulness. A look at the world conflicts in the last 20 years has involved these nations one way or another. Of course I don't condone the rampant usage of such weapons but neither do I believe in drawing out a war!
"Over and Out"








